Buying guides · Feeding

How to choose a breast pump: manual, electric, double or wearable

By Youpili Updated 11 min read

Key takeaways

How to choose a breast pump depends on how often you will pump: a manual pump for now and then, a double electric pump for daily pumping or going back to work, a wearable pump if you need to move around. Before you buy, check your health insurance: under the Affordable Care Act, most plans must cover a breast pump.

Contents
  1. Types of breast pump compared
  2. Insurance, renting or buying?
  3. Which breast pump for your situation?
  4. What really matters when choosing
  5. Getting started with your breast pump
  6. Cleaning and storage: the right habits
  7. How much does a breast pump cost?
  8. Mistakes to avoid
  9. A breast pump on your baby registry
  10. Where this information comes from

How to choose a breast pump depends above all on how often you will pump. For occasional use, such as a night out or relieving a breast that feels too full, a manual pump is often enough. For daily use, especially when you go back to work, a double electric pump saves a lot of time. Before you buy anything, check your health insurance: under the Affordable Care Act, most health plans must cover a breast pump, either a rental or a new one you keep, as well as breastfeeding support and counseling.

This guide compares the different types of breast pump, helps you decide between insurance, renting and buying, and shows how to fit one into your online baby registry. It does not replace the support of your OB-GYN or midwife, your pediatrician or a lactation consultant (IBCLC), which is invaluable if feeding is not going as you hoped.

Types of breast pump compared

Prices vary a lot depending on power, noise and the accessories included; these are rough ranges for new equipment in the US, before any insurance coverage.

Type Best for Speed Pros Cons Rough price
Manual Occasional use: a night out, a trip, relieving fullness Slow, one breast at a time Light, quiet, no battery, low price; a useful backup during a power outage Tiring for your hand if you end up pumping every day Around $15 to $50
Single electric A few sessions a week Medium, one breast at a time Speed and suction settings, less effort Noisier, needs an outlet or charging Around $50 to $150
Double electric Daily use, going back to work, feeding pumped milk by bottle Fast, both breasts at once Saves a lot of time; often the type covered by insurance Bulkier and more expensive Around $100 to $350
Wearable Pumping while you move around or work Varies from one model to another Fits inside your bra, no tubes Trickier to fit well, high price, smaller capacity Around $100 to $500
Rented multi-user pump (often called “hospital-grade”) Intensive use, a difficult start, a baby in the NICU Fast Powerful machine without buying one, returned when you no longer need it Has to be returned, a new personal accessory kit to buy Sometimes covered by insurance; otherwise a monthly rental fee that varies

Insurance, renting or buying?

It is often the first question to ask, before you even look at models.

  • Through your health insurance: under the Affordable Care Act, Marketplace plans and all other health plans, except grandfathered plans, must cover a breast pump. Your plan may decide whether it is a rental or a new pump you keep, whether it is manual or electric, and whether you get it before or after the birth; some require pre-authorization from your doctor. Call your plan during pregnancy to find out the rules and where to order. If you have Medicaid, ask your state program; WIC can also help some families get a pump.
  • Renting a multi-user pump, from a hospital or a medical supply provider, gives you a powerful pump without a big outlay. The FDA notes that each renter must buy a new accessory kit (breast shields and tubing): the parts that touch your breast and your milk stay personal.
  • Buying makes sense if your plan’s model does not suit you, if you want a quiet or wearable pump for work, or for occasional use with an inexpensive manual pump.

Coverage and rental terms vary from one plan and one area to another; your plan, your OB-GYN’s office or the hospital’s lactation team can tell you what is available. The CDC page on breast milk storage and preparation covers the basics once you start pumping.

Which breast pump for your situation?

You are breastfeeding and just want a little flexibility

A manual pump is enough to prepare the occasional bottle, leave your baby with someone for an evening or relieve a breast that feels too full. It fits in a bag and needs neither an outlet nor a battery. Hand expression is also an option, with no equipment at all.

You are going back to work and continuing to breastfeed

A double electric pump, or a wearable one if there is nowhere easy to go for some privacy, cuts the length of each session. Under the federal PUMP Act, most employers must give you reasonable break time to pump each time you need to, for one year after your baby’s birth, and a place other than a bathroom that is shielded from view and free from intrusion from coworkers and the public. Breaks do not have to be paid unless you are not completely relieved from duty; employers with fewer than 50 employees may be exempt if compliance would cause undue hardship. Remote workers have the same rights. Some states go further: talk to your employer or HR before your leave ends.

Your baby is premature or in the hospital

The NICU team will advise you and will often help you use a powerful multi-user pump, at the hospital and sometimes at home. This is a situation where the support of the care team comes before anything else.

You are feeding your baby only pumped milk

You will pump several times a day, so a double electric pump, covered, rented or bought, is close to essential. Plan for spare breast shields and a second set of parts to swap while the first one is being cleaned.

You want to build up a supply before going back to work

Many moms start pumping a few weeks before returning to work, to stock the freezer and get their baby used to a bottle. An electric pump makes these regular sessions more comfortable. Ask your pediatrician or a lactation consultant when to start, ideally once breastfeeding feels well established.

You are expecting twins

Double pumping saves precious time. Ask for support from the start, at the hospital, as fitting feedings and pumping sessions around two babies takes a little organizing.

You do not know yet whether you will breastfeed

Do not buy one in advance: your insurance may cover a pump anyway. You can add it to your registry as an idea, without marking it as a priority, or turn on the cash fund so you can rent or buy one later if you need it.

What really matters when choosing

Breast shield size

This is the most often overlooked detail. The FDA advises making sure the breast shield (or flange) opening is the right size: you should be able to center your nipple comfortably inside it. A shield that is the wrong size makes pumping uncomfortable and less effective. Many pumps come with a single size, but manufacturers often offer others: a lactation consultant can help you choose.

Settings

Electric pumps usually have a stimulation phase, then an expression phase, with several suction levels. Start on a low setting, then increase once your milk is flowing. Pumping should not hurt.

Noise and battery life

If you pump at night or at work, a quiet motor and a rechargeable battery make day-to-day life much easier.

Number of parts

Every part that touches your milk needs cleaning after each use. The fewer there are, the quicker the cleaning. Check that spare parts, such as valves and membranes, are easy to find.

Compatibility

A pump that attaches straight to your bottles or storage containers saves pouring milk from one container to another. Less handling also means less risk of spilling precious milk, and it saves time when you are pumping at work between two meetings.

Getting started with your breast pump

The first sessions often feel strange. A few simple habits make them easier:

  • Pick a calm moment, sit comfortably and keep a glass of water within reach.
  • Wash your hands before handling the pump parts and containers.
  • Start on the gentlest setting, then increase gradually to a level that stays comfortable.
  • Do not judge by quantity at first: it varies from one session to the next and from one person to another, and says nothing about how breastfeeding is going.
  • Prepare a complete kit in advance: breast shields, valves, labeled containers, and an insulated cooler with ice packs if you pump away from home.

If sessions stay difficult or painful, a visit with a lactation consultant (IBCLC) can often fix a setting or a shield size, and many health plans cover breastfeeding counseling.

Cleaning and storage: the right habits

The CDC advises cleaning all the pump parts that touch your breast or milk as soon as possible after each session, and sanitizing them at least once a day for extra germ removal, which matters most if your baby is under 2 months, was born prematurely or has a weakened immune system. Tubing that stays dry does not need routine cleaning; throw it away if milk or mold gets inside. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions for each part. For storing freshly pumped milk, the CDC gives these maximum times:

  • up to 4 hours at room temperature (77°F or colder);
  • up to 4 days in the refrigerator (40°F), at the back rather than in the door;
  • about 6 months in the freezer (0°F or colder) for best quality, up to 12 months acceptable.

Label each container with the date, carry milk in an insulated cooler with frozen ice packs for up to 24 hours, use thawed milk within 24 hours (kept in the fridge) and never refreeze it. The CDC website covers the other precautions, such as thawing and leftovers.

How much does a breast pump cost?

Without insurance, allow around $15 to $50 for a manual pump, $50 to $350 for an electric pump depending on whether it is single or double, and $100 to $500 for a wearable one. With insurance, the covered model may cost you little or nothing, and some parents pay the difference for an upgrade. On top of that come the accessories: storage bottles or bags, breast shields in different sizes, nursing pads and a cooler bag to carry your milk.

Secondhand is a bad idea for a breast pump: the FDA considers most breast pumps single-user devices, because there is no way to guarantee they can be cleaned and disinfected between users, and a used pump may void the warranty. Only rental pumps designed for multiple users can be shared, with a new personal kit. Our guide to secondhand and renting for your baby covers the items that are fine to reuse.

To see where this fits among your other costs, see what having a baby really costs. You can add a pump or accessories from any store to your registry by pasting the product link.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Buying a top-of-the-line pump before checking your insurance, which may cover one for free.
  • Sticking with the wrong breast shield size just because it came with the pump.
  • Turning the suction up to maximum to go faster: it often does the opposite, and it hurts.
  • Ignoring pain that does not go away: mention it quickly to your OB-GYN, midwife or a lactation consultant.
  • Forgetting spare parts: a worn valve is enough to make the pump less effective.
  • Borrowing someone else’s single-user pump: the FDA advises against sharing pumps.

A breast pump on your baby registry

A breast pump is not one of the 42 essentials in our baby registry checklist: it depends on how breastfeeding goes, and often on your insurance. There are still several ways to plan for one:

  • If your plan does not cover the model you want, add it, with the breast shield size in the note for your guests if you know it.
  • For an expensive wearable pump or an upgrade, suggest it as a group gift at your baby shower or turn on the cash fund: friends and family contribute, and you decide after the birth. Our guide to the baby cash fund explains how it works.
  • With “Add it yourself”, you can also create an item called “Breast pump rental” with an approximate price.
  • Pumping accessories (storage bags, extra breast shields, a cooler bag) make welcome small gifts.
  • A visit with a private lactation consultant can also be a gift, if your plan does not cover one: an idea that sits well with our experience gifts for a new baby.

To balance your registry as a whole, our guide to baby registry budget gives pointers by price range, and our checklist of newborn essentials covers the other feeding items, such as the nursing pillow.

Where this information comes from

Cleaning and storage: these pointers come from the CDC; insurance coverage from HealthCare.gov; workplace rights from the Department of Labor; single-user and rental pumps from the FDA. For the pumps themselves, we rely on manufacturers’ specifications, without testing products ourselves and without preferring any brand. Every breastfeeding journey is different: if you have pain, sore or cracked nipples, worries about your supply or any doubt, talk to your OB-GYN, midwife or pediatrician, or ask for a lactation consultant (IBCLC). If you are eligible, WIC also offers breastfeeding support. Prices are given as rough guides only.

Frequently asked questions

How to choose a breast pump depends on how often you pump. A manual pump suits occasional use: a night out, the occasional bottle, relieving fullness. An electric pump is better if you pump every day, especially when you go back to work. A double electric pump, which pumps both breasts at once, saves the most time.

Yes, in most cases. Under the Affordable Care Act, Marketplace plans and all other health plans, except grandfathered plans, must cover a breast pump, either a rental or a new one you keep, as well as breastfeeding support and counseling. Your plan may set rules on the type of pump and when you get it, so call it during pregnancy.

Usually there is no need to buy a breast pump before the birth. Start by checking what your insurance covers, as some plans send a pump before your due date. You do not yet know how breastfeeding will start, so it is better to decide on an upgrade or a wearable pump once your baby is here, with advice from a lactation consultant.

A double breast pump expresses milk from both breasts at the same time, using two breast shields connected to the same motor. Sessions are shorter than with a single pump. It is mostly useful for daily pumping: going back to work, feeding your baby only pumped milk, twins or a baby in the NICU.

The breast shield, or flange, should match the size of your nipple: the FDA says you should be able to center your nipple comfortably inside it. Too small or too large, it makes pumping uncomfortable and less effective. Many pumps come with one size, but other sizes are often available, and a lactation consultant can help you find the right one.

Yes. The CDC advises cleaning every pump part that touches your breast or milk as soon as possible after each use, and sanitizing them at least once a day, especially if your baby is under 2 months, was born prematurely or has a weakened immune system. You can boil them, use steam or a dishwasher with hot water and heated drying, following the manufacturer's instructions.

According to the CDC, freshly pumped breast milk can be kept up to 4 hours at room temperature (77°F or colder), up to 4 days in the refrigerator and about 6 months in the freezer for best quality, up to 12 months acceptable. Label each container with the date, and never refreeze milk that has been thawed.

It is not recommended. The FDA considers most breast pumps single-user devices, because they cannot be guaranteed clean between users, and sharing one can pass on infectious particles. Only rental pumps designed for multiple users can be shared, with a new personal accessory kit. Check your insurance first: a new pump may be covered.

Ready to start your baby registry?

Free, with gifts from any store, and easy to share with family and friends.